Subject: Re: [modeller_usage] homomultimers and symmetry
From: Modeller Caretaker <>
Date: Mon, 19 Jun 2006 11:22:22 -0700
Cc: ModellerUsage List <>
Mike White wrote:
I am new to hands-on experience with Modeller. I would like to
create a homology model of the protein that I am interested in as a
homopentamer, using known homopentamer X-ray structures of related
proteins. I have run across several questions in the archives about
imposing symmetry constraints in the modeling process. Is it
necessary to impose such constraints if the template is already a
homopentamer with 5-fold symmetry? Doesn't this by itself impose
symmetry constraints? Or, is it possible that an energy-minimized
structure based on a symmetric template may not retain all of the
symmetry of the template and the symmetry restraints make sure that
the original symmetry is forced to be retained?
If your template is 5-fold symmetric, it is likely that the model will
also be 5-fold symmetric, although this of course depends on your
alignment. Symmetry restraints are more useful if you know something
about the symmetry of your model, rather than the templates, although
you can certainly impose whatever restraints you like if the model isn't
behaving in the way you think it should.
Finally, since model.symmetry.define() deals with pairs, does one
enforce pentameric symmetry in the complex by forcing AB, BC, CD, DE,
and EA symmetry, where A-E are the five individual subunits in the
homopentamer?